Sunday, September 29, 2013

First in the Ring : Atkins Induction


Today the diet-trials began. I woke up this morning in my usual state : cold, grumpy and more than a bit hungry. Normally, I'd drown my morning woes in whole grain cereal with milk and a giant cup of coffee. Any conversation I'd engage in would consist largely of grunts. But not this morning. Atkins Induction allows neither cereal nor milk, and only a limited amount of coffee. (jury is still out about the grunting) To make matters worse, this means I have to cook breakfast.

Ten minutes later, I've fried up a three-egg, spinach and feta scramble which proceeds to get cold as I wash my fry-pan. It looked pitifully small on my plate. (pictured above) Humph. So far, this diet thing is turning out to be just as irritating as I'd imagined.

After eating, I'm less grumpy, although the food feels awfully leaden in my stomach. I sit down to count out how many carbohydrates I've consumed thus far. According to Atkins and my food labels, I've consumed a 1.75 grams of carbohydrate and no fiber. My normal cereal and milk would have me at approximately 35 grams of carbohydrate and 3.5 grams of dietary fiber.

Most traditional diets recommend the individual obtain approximately 45% to 60% of their calories from the carbohydrates in their diet. The majority of these carbohydrates are broken down in the body into glucose, which travels through the bloodstream to provide fuel for almost all of the important functions in the body. For a person who consumes 1,800 Calories (kcal) each day, this breaks down to approximately 225 grams of carbohydrates each day. Atkins Induction pushes an ultra-low carbohydrate approach which demands the individual consume less than 20 grams of carbohydrate in a day.

This ultra-low carbohydrate consumption pushes the body into a state known as ketosis, in which the liver converts the fat in the diet into fatty acids and ketone bodies. The ketone bodies serve to replace glucose as the main fuel source in the body. This, in turn, reduces the insulin production, as insulin's main function is to carry glucose to various locations in the body.

Theoretically, the ketogenic nature of Atkins Induction reduces body mass by reducing blood glucose and insulin production, which they purport to be the main cause of obesity. The body has to work harder to make the fats and proteins pushed by Atkins into fuel, and thus, despite consuming higher numbers of calories, the individual loses weight.*

In order to continue to obtain all of the necessary vitamins and minerals to be healthy, most all of the carbohydrates allowed in Atkins induction are non-fibrous vegetables. Due to their low calorie and high micronutrient profiles, these vegetables make the ideal low-carb, high-nutrient source of carbohydrates. It is recommended that of the 20 grams of carbs allowed, 12-15 of them come from such vegetables.

As for the rest of what I'm allowed to eat on Atkins Induction, it is pretty simple. The list consists mostly of meats, fish, seafood, hard cheeses, oils and fats, spices, broths, the foundation vegetables, and lots of water. I'm not allowed any fruit, grains, milk or desserts (except sugar free gelatin) and I have to track the carbohydrates of any food I consume. Its going to be a strange few weeks, but we'll see how it goes. I doubt I will ever stop being grumpy at breakfast, but maybe ketosis can change me.

* Once again, I'd like to state that it is not my goal to lose weight on these diets. I will certainly record it if I do, but I am more interested in what it is like to live on these diets, and how doing so changes my view of how I eat.


For a complete list of allowed foods, click here.

For guidelines about Atkins Induction, click here.


Sources :

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atkins_diet
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ketogenic_diet



Thursday, September 26, 2013

Love me as I am.

In the interest of observing the physiological changes these diets will have on me, I have taken a baseline on my vital stats as I am now.

Here is where I stand:

Height : 65 in

Weight : 110-111 lbs (depending on when I weigh myself)

BMI : 18.4 - as calculated by the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute

Measurements : 32 in  - 24.5 in - 34 in

Resting Heart Rate : 71 bpm on 9/4/13

Blood Pressure : 125/70 on 9/4/13

Body Fat Percentage :  19% - as estimated by the US Navy method*, aka: the rope and choke
              This means I carry ~ 21 lbs of fat on my body, 11-14 lbs of which is considered essential **

*I am aware that the rope and choke is considered highly inaccurate as a true measure of body fat percentage. (as opposed to calipers or hydrostatic weighing) It is, however, cheap and easy to measure. I am including it as a method of comparison among the diets, not as a reflection of my actual fat percentage.

** For more information on Body Fat Percentage click here


Wednesday, September 25, 2013

Happy Hunger Games!

The four competing diets have been chosen! Each is unique in its demands and design, and should provide me with individualized challenges. Which one are you rooting for?

A hearty shoutout to all of you who assisted me in designing this battle of the diets; this plan would have been much less interesting, and far more convoluted, without your input.

Diet 1 : Starting September 29th - Atkins: Induction Phase as designed by Dr. Robert Atkins, M.D.

Diet 2 : Starting October 20th - Original Paleo as designed by Dr. Lauren Cordain, PhD.

Diet 3 : Starting November 10th - Vegan (mostly) Raw Diet - this one I'm on my own for, but thanks to V. Galli for the inspiration

Diet 4 : Starting December 1st - The Blood Type Diet as designed by Dr. Peter D'Adamo, ND.

As you can see, each diet lasts three weeks, 12 weeks total, with no breaks in between. I am not planning on doing any cheat days, though I guarantee I'll slip up at some point, because, well, I'm human. Hopefully, I'll learn something in the process.

May the odds be ever in your favor!

Many thanks to B. Benskin, P. Benskin, S. Kelly, K. Haas, P. Bowlin, V. Galli and especially to my Mom, for being my soundboard for my half baked theories and rants, and for agreeing to this crazy scheme.

Tuesday, September 24, 2013

It was the Best of times, it was the Worst of times...

Here's the thing about me : I don't like to be wrong. I will fight and defend my position as long as I have argument to do so. However, if you show me the error of my ways, in a logical and grounded manner, after a fit of righteous indignation, I will generally concede the point. Yes, I was wrong. (you irritating buffoon) Except, of course, when it comes to my food.

I have been some version of vegetarian for over half of my life, and I am stuck in my ways. When I decided to go back to school just one year ago, I knew I wanted to work in healthcare. After much deliberation, I decided to pursue a career in dietetics. While I am still several years away from ever officially giving people advice on their food, people continue to ask me what I think anyway. And this is where my staunchly-held beliefs come in. I recommend what I know. Yet, I do not have the education to be making these recommendations to others.

Then, it dawned on me, after one spirited debate about the merits of Paleo, that I'm a hypocrite. Yes, I believe vegetarianism is better, and I have plenty of reasons for thinking so, but, and this is a big BUT, it is all I have ever experienced. So, one day, during a particularly long shower, I cooked up the idea of trying out some of the various diets out there, living by their tenants, following their, at times ridiculous, rules. It seemed like a good way to educate myself about what each of the diets entails, and the science behind them.

Initially, I planned on spending one week on each diet, pretty much to minimize the harm I was certain I would be inflicting upon my body. However, as one friend so astutely pointed out, then I would be missing all of the purported benefits of these plans.

The plan then began to form, three weeks on each diet, four diets, twelve weeks in total. A trial of the diets, so to speak. Pitting them against one another is the hallowed halls of my kitchen. Then, I thought, I should write about it, and here we are. This blog shall be my record of the highs, lows and in-betweens of my personal diet experiment.


* As a side note, I would like to point out that I am not testing these diets for their weight loss capabilities, as I am currently at a healthy weight. Rather, my aim is to study how I feel on the diet, on both a physical and emotional level.